Meet Our Amazing Team

Beverly Fenello

Serving as Team Owner, Leader and Senior Agent at the Fenello Real Estate Group, Beverly is a top-performing real estate pro with more than 18 years of experience in the industry, working with buyers, sellers and real estate investors. 

A South Carolina native, Beverly has lived in Atlanta since 1997, making her an expert guide on the community itself. She found her niche in real estate back in 2003 when she began with Keller Williams Realty, and previously enjoyed a 25-year career in sales. 

Experienced in all fields of real estate, Beverly’s strengths include buying and selling strategies. investment properties, short sales, foreclosures, building and construction, residential financing, business brokerage, and communicating  current real estate trends.

She provides strong market analysis and is a strategic negotiator with a thorough understanding of real estate contracts and requirements. She also maintains a strong network of top brokers and agents within the industry, and is a member of the Cherokee Board of REALTORS® with certifications that include ABR (Accredited Buyer’s Representative), SRES (Seniors Real Estate Specialist) and PSA (Pricing Strategy Advisor). 

Her favorite part of the job continues to be the strong relationships she builds with clients, becoming more than just a real estate agent, but a friend and advisor as well.

In addition to her passion for real estate, Beverly enjoys being a  member of Northpoint Community Church, participating as a small group leader for the Middle School Ministry and serving on the Host Team as well. She also enjoys hiking, entertaining, playing pickleball and spending time with her husband and two sweet cats. 

Jay Fenello

As a Team Agent and Business Broker for the Fenello Real Estate Group, Jay specializes in real estate sales, investments and business brokerage. 

He has achieved the CDPE (Certified Distressed Property Expert) and CBB (Certified Business Brokerage) designations, and has repeatedly been recognized as one of the top business brokers in the state by the Georgia Association of Business Brokers.

Prior to his real estate career, Jay was active in the computer and Internet industries.

Jay is currently a member of the Atlanta Commercial Board of REALTORS®.


Michael Bogatay

Michael is a versatile Team Agent for the Fenello Real Estate Group, working with both buyers and sellers, and also specializing in military relocation to and from the greater Atlanta area. Having served on U.S. Navy submarines for eight years, as well as stationed at several bases around the U.S. and overseas, Michael has first-hand experience with the challenges that service members and their families face during the PCS (Permanent Change of Station) process, and knows just how to ensure a seamless transition for them. 

Prior to joining the Fenello Group, Michael retired from the defense industry, where he managed the development and production of precision laser designators and rangefinders for U.S. Special Forces; the overhaul and modernization of U.S. Air Force Presidential aircraft, and the development and installation of electronic systems modifications to DC-9, P-3, C-130 and L-1011 aircraft. 

Michael is a member of the Cobb Association of REALTORS® with certifications that include Military Relocation Professional (MRP) and 55+ Realty Advisor. 

Outside of real estate, Michael enjoys quality time with his wife, children and grandchildren, catches as many college football games as possible, maintains his currency as a private pilot, and with his brother, refurbishes classic automobiles to their former glory.  He also attends St. James Episcopal Church in Marietta.  

Cheryl Johnson

Cheryl is a Team Agent for the Fenello Real Estate Group, serving as both a Buyer’s Agent and Seller’s Agent. Representing Atlanta homeowners, and future homeowners, she strives to demonstrate the highest level of integrity, a commitment to listening, and utilizes her keen negotiating skills to ensure successful transactions. Cheryl’s clients know they can trust their partnership. Through positive collaboration, she builds lifelong relationships with her clients.

Cheryl is a Georgian native to Cobb and Cherokee counties, and therefore understands the numerous intangible benefits of life in Atlanta, with its unmatched culture and diversities.

Previously working in business management, Cheryl has a degree in Interior Design to help both buyers and sellers envision a particular home or space for all that it is, and all that it can become. She is also a member of the Cobb Association of REALTORS®.

In her personal life, Cheryl spends every moment she can with her beautiful family, including four children and three dogs. As a true foodie, she enjoys exploring different restaurants, diving into all things health and wellness, patronizing neighboring small businesses and volunteering in her community.


Susan Aylsworth

Susan works as both a Buyer’s Agent and a Listing Agent for the Fenello Real Estate Group, providing additional administrative and marketing support to the team as well. As a Woodstock native for more than 20 years, she is an incredible resource for the latest information on the Northwest Atlanta area. 

Prior to joining the Fenello Group, Susan enjoyed a 28-year career with one of the nation’s top multi-family housing companies. Her deep understanding of the industry and unrivaled expertise provided a natural segue into real estate, making her a knowledgeable asset to any client. Susan is also a member of the Cherokee Association of REALTORS®. 

When she’s not helping clients with their real estate transactions, Susan can be found working in her yard, reading and going to muscle car shows. She’s also an active member of the St. Peter Chanel Catholic Church in Roswell.


Don’t Hesitate. Please call us today at (404) 915-7869.